Deep Fishing Rarity: Tiers, Rarest Fish, Mutations and Luck
Scope: Compiled from the complete Roblox badge, game-pass, developer-product and event APIs read at 02:18 UTC on 21 October 2026, the developer's Mutation Roll + Rarity patch list, community fish and rod tables dated 19 September to 6 October 2026, and an in-game screen check on 21 October 2026.
Key points
- Official records name four tiers above the everyday catch: Legendary, Mythical and Secret (badges) and Exotic (September patch list).
- Mutations are a separate layer; 85% of Welcome! badge holders also hold First Mutation, against 10.5% for First Secret.
- Luck comes from rods (up to 1,050%), three luck passes, Server Luck x2–x16, Luck Potions, one-throw boosts and the Big Mouth Fish.
- The only official percentage is a 0.1% Rekin Shark chance inside the Mutation Reroll; no general drop table is published.
On this page
- What rarity tiers are in Deep Fishing?
- Which fish are the rarest?
- How do mutations work in Deep Fishing?
- How do you increase your luck?
- What do the public badge counters show?
- Why can't first-catch badges reveal a drop rate?
- What does the Admin Chest drop?
- How should you plan a rarity-hunting session?
- Rarity FAQ
- Correction history
- Sources
- Related guides
Deep Fishing's official records name four high tiers: Legendary, Mythical, Secret and Exotic. Mutations sit on top of those as a separate layer. Rarity rises with distance: the developer's description promises "new waters with rarer fish", and community fish lists put sharks, prehistoric creatures and boss-tier catches in the far rings. This page brings together what the badge list, the patch notes, the store and community tables say. It also explains why badge totals cannot be read as drop rates.
What rarity tiers are in Deep Fishing?
| Tier | Official evidence | What else is known |
|---|---|---|
| Legendary | "First Legendary" badge: "You caught your first Legendary!" | 1,820,474 awards on 21 Oct 2026 |
| Mythical | "First Mythical" badge | 1,292,059 awards. AllThingsHow also mentions Mythical Lucky Chests hooked on long casts |
| Secret | "First Secret" badge | 438,537 awards. The September patch added a "Secret / Exotic Pull Cutscene" and a hatch minigame |
| Exotic | "Mutation Roll + Rarity" patch (5–11 Sep 2026): "Added the new Exotic rarity" | 5 Exotic fish added to World 1 and 4 to World 2. No Exotic badge exists |
| Mutated (any tier) | "First Mutation" badge: "You caught your first Mutated Fish!" | A modifier on a fish, not a tier of its own (AllThingsHow) |
None of the records names the lower tiers, and none sets out a full order. Exotic appears beside Secret in two patch lines, but neither line ranks one above the other. Check the fish detail screen in your Index for the label shown in your version.
Which fish are the rarest?
The developer has not published a fish list. AllThingsHow's catalogue (24 Sep 2026) counts 101 fish: 35 at Fernshore, 34 at Dunehaven, 28 at Frostmere and 4 exclusives. It does not give rarity labels. It does say rarity rises with distance from shore.
| Fish | Why it is hard to get | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Rekin (Rekin Shark) | "0.1% chance to get Rekin Shark" in the Mutation Reroll section of the patch list | Official patch list; also in AllThingsHow's exclusive list |
| Big Mouth | "Feed it every 12 Hours"; "Complete the Luck boost to get Big Mouth Fish" | Official patch list |
| Crownbreaker Leviathan | Listed as an exclusive | AllThingsHow |
| Colossal Kraken | Listed as an exclusive. The "Toxic + Kraken" event (20–27 Sep 2026) was named after a kraken and promised "New Mutation, Boss & more" | AllThingsHow; official event listing |
| Large species such as Megalodon, Leviathan, Kraken, Mosasaurus and Blue Whale | Named in the island lists; the same source places sharks, prehistoric creatures and boss-tier catches in the deep rings | AllThingsHow |
New worlds keep adding fish. The volcano world (Emberdeep) was announced with 30 fish. The Halloween World listing, 18–23 Oct 2026, advertises "New Fish, Mutation & more".
How do mutations work in Deep Fishing?
Every mutation-related item in the official records:
| Source | What it says | Robux |
|---|---|---|
| Mutation Reroll (patch list) | "Reroll the mutation of your caught fish for a chance at something better!" | 49 for one; 16.99 each in the x100 |
| Fish Mutation Scrolls (patch list) | "Fish Mutation Scrolls if lucky" | Ultra Mutation Scroll 129 for one |
| Size up and down (patch list) | The reroll can also change a fish's size | — |
| More Mutations pass | "Find more mutated Fishes! 🧬" | 349 |
| Mutation Luck (One Throw) | Name only | 19 |
| "Toxic + Kraken" event | Subtitle: "New Mutation, Boss & more" | — |
| "Halloween World" event | Subtitle: "New Fish, Mutation & more" | — |
On 21 October a Mutation Reroll stall stood in the shore hub. AllThingsHow says mutations act as a value modifier and that a Mutation Scroll can turn up with Meadow Bait. Per-unit prices for every reroll and scroll bundle are in the shop guide.
How do you increase your luck?
| Luck source | Size | Duration | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Base luck | Shown as "Luck 100%" on a new account | Always | In-game screen, 21 Oct 2026 |
| Rods | From 10% (Iron) to 1,050% (Galaxy) | While equipped | Community rod tables |
| Lucky / Super Lucky / Ultra Lucky passes | "better", "even more", "The best luck boost!" | Permanent | Official pass descriptions; 99 / 249 / 599 Robux |
| Server Luck x2, x4, x8, x16 | Multiplier in the name | Not stated | Developer products; 99–999 Robux |
| Luck Potion | Not stated | A session | Code rewards (Dexerto, games.gg) |
| Mutation Luck (One Throw) | Not stated | One throw | Developer product; 19 Robux |
| Big Mouth Fish | "Feeding it grants Permanent Luck boost" | Permanent | Official patch list |
AllThingsHow advises building distance before luck, because no luck boost helps a cast that cannot reach the deep water where rare fish live. Its rod order runs Bronze, Full Bronze, then Steel.
What do the public badge counters show?
Read from the official badge list on 21 October 2026 at 02:18 UTC.
| Badge | Requirement | Total awards | Awarded in the past day | Share of Welcome! total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Welcome! | You played Deep Fishing! | 4,170,098 | 103,879 | 100% |
| First Mutation | You caught your first Mutated Fish! | 3,545,116 | 87,653 | 85.0% |
| 50 Catches | You caught 50 Fish! | 2,749,940 | 68,933 | 65.9% |
| First Legendary | You caught your first Legendary! | 1,820,474 | 44,881 | 43.7% |
| First Mythical | You caught your first Mythical! | 1,292,059 | 30,126 | 31.0% |
| First Secret | You caught your first Secret! | 438,537 | 11,493 | 10.5% |
The share column is one counter divided by another. It shows how many accounts have reached each milestone. It is not the chance per cast. All 13 badges, including the catch counts up to 500K, are on the badge page.
Why can't first-catch badges reveal a drop rate?
Take two players who each earn First Secret once: one after 10 casts, the other after 10,000. The counter goes up by one for each, even though their chances were very different. A first-catch badge also stops counting that player's later Secret catches. The endpoint does not report cast counts, play time or overlap between badges. The badge API's winRatePercentage field is not a per-cast rate either.
To estimate a rate yourself, record every eligible cast, including empty ones. Keep the water, rod, bait and boosts fixed, and count both the qualifying catches and the total casts. Small samples are noisy, and the result only holds for those conditions.
What does the Admin Chest drop?
No source we found publishes a complete Admin Chest drop table for Deep Fishing. None of the 124 developer products listed on 4 November 2026 is named Admin Chest, and no event listing mentions one. The chests that appear in the records are the four purchasable Lucky Chest families: Pirate, Element, Charm and Hero, from 79 to 799 Robux. AllThingsHow also reports Mythical Lucky Chests from long casts, with one paying $12,403 coins.
Be careful with "Admin Crate" loot lists: that name belongs to Fisch, a different Roblox game. Before relying on any chest list, match the game, the exact chest name and the update, and check that the source shows the full reward screen. The shop guide lists every chest price.
How should you plan a rarity-hunting session?
- Pick a target from the badge list. First Mutation has 85% as many awards as Welcome!, while First Secret has about one in ten.
- Upgrade distance first. Rare fish live farther out, and the gear page has the rod ladder with community coin prices.
- Stack free luck before paid luck: rod luck, Luck Potions from codes and the Big Mouth Fish's permanent boost.
- Before buying a luck pass or Server Luck, read its exact description in the purchase prompt. The game pass guide lists all ten.
- For mutations, reroll in bundles of 10 or more. The x5 bundle costs more per reroll than the x3.
Rarity FAQ
What is the rarest rarity in Deep Fishing?
Secret and Exotic are the two highest tiers named in official records. The developer added Exotic in September 2026 alongside a special pull cutscene for both, without saying which ranks higher. First Secret is the rarest first-catch badge: 438,537 awards on 21 October 2026.
What is the chance to get Rekin Shark?
The developer's patch list gives "0.1% chance to get Rekin Shark" in its Mutation Reroll section. That figure applies to the reroll mechanic, not to ordinary casts.
Are mutations a tier above Secret?
No. A mutation is a separate modifier on a caught fish. The badge list tracks First Mutation separately from the tier badges, and AllThingsHow describes mutations as a value modifier.
Does More Mutations stack with luck passes?
The pass descriptions don't say. More Mutations says only "Find more mutated Fishes!"; the luck passes give no numbers.
How do I get the Big Mouth Fish?
According to the official patch list, you feed the Big Mouth every 12 hours to earn a permanent luck boost, and completing that boost gives you the fish. A Robux product, Skip Big Mouth Timer (79 Robux), exists for the wait.
Correction history
On 16 October 2026 an earlier version that treated badge totals as a rarity chart was corrected. The 21 October revision refreshes all counters and adds the tier, fish, mutation and luck tables from the sources listed below.
Sources
The mechanics and numbers in this guide come from the material below. Open the original pages to check them yourself.
- S001 official badge list badges.roblox.com Accessed
- S002 apis.roblox.com apis.roblox.com Accessed
- S003 apis.roblox.com apis.roblox.com Accessed
- S004 apis.roblox.com apis.roblox.com Accessed
- S005 games.roblox.com games.roblox.com Accessed
- S006 allthings.how allthings.how Accessed
- S007 allthings.how allthings.how Accessed
- S008 allthings.how allthings.how Accessed
- S009 vacancybee.com vacancybee.com Accessed
- S010 www.dexerto.com www.dexerto.com Accessed
- S011 games.gg games.gg Accessed